Ecosystem-based management
Why is it
necessary for ecosystems to be managed by humans? This is a good question
because ecosystems have existed naturally, with various living species, and
maintained various systems long before human society was built up. Therefore it
would be better if humans did not interfere with natural ecosystems at
all.
Here, an
explanation will be given about "ecosystem-based management " or
"ecosystem management". These expressions make it sound like natural
ecosystems are under the control of humans, but is that actually necessary? The
word "management" is not "control" but
"management". "Ecosystem-based management" is applied
science to conserve ecosystems that have a complicated relationship with human
society based on the latest knowledge in scientific ecology.
The most
important thing in the past used to be managing natural resources in a way that
maximized yields. Eventually, we learned to balance production and consumption,
in order to avoid exploiting our resources without any restriction. However
ecosystem services and biodiversity were never a primary concern, provision
services always took priority.
The science of
"conservation biology" started to gain popularity in the 1980's, when
the importance of conserving biodiversity was recognized. With this new view
emerging it was remarkably improper to only consider the quantity of resources.
Especially from the end of the 20th century to the beginning of the 21st
century, there was much more support and clarification of the importance of
diversity to maintain ecosystem services that human society receives (Millennium
Ecosystem Assessment 2005). This knowledge lead to the realization that perhaps
the best way to manage an ecosystem is to respect its inherent natural
processes.
The table below
shows the change from the classical views of traditional resource management
(so-called "steady-state resource management") to the new views on
ecosystem-based management. However, in spite of the development of
ecosystem-based management paradigm, many environmental policies still focus
only on "balance of nature ", and try to eliminate variability and
changes. (Mori 2011a, 2011b).
An ecosystem is
very diverse, so predicting when and where changes will happen is difficult in
present science (unpredictability). What makes it even harder is that changes
beyond our expectations are happening all the time (uncertainty). Before it was
thought that these natural systems called ecosystems had a stable unchanging
condition (equilibrium concept), however as ecology progressed it was getting
clearer that these natural systems are full of uncertainty and unpredictability
(Non-equilibrium concept).
In addition to
adaptive management, there is considerable concentration on co-management when
it comes to ecosystem-based management. In co-management, various stakeholders
can participate in decision-making equally. It is not a management system based
on a top-down system from governments or scientists, or a system where
governments make final decisions.
As it is
currently thought impossible to separate humans or society from ecosystems
(Chapin et al. 2009), it is necessary to explore sustainability to maintain
ecosystem services that human society permanently receive while paying special
attention to complex interactions between society and nature. This is
"ecosystem-based management".
Table. Ecosystem-based
management as a paradigm shift (UNEP/GPA 2006).
From |
To |
Individual
species |
Ecosystems |
Small
spatial scale |
Multiple
scales |
Short-term
perspective |
Long-term
perspective |
Humans
independent of ecosystems |
Humans as
integral parts of ecosystems |
Management
divorced from research |
Adaptive
management |
Managing
commodities |
Sustained
production potential for ecosystem goods and services |
References
Chapin, F.S.
III., Kofinas, G.P., Folke, C. (2009) Principles of ecosystem stewardship.
Resilience-based natural resource management in a changing world. Springer, New
York, USA.
Millennium
Ecosystem Assessment (2005) Ecosystems and human well-being: current state and
trends: Findings of the Condition and Trends Working Group. Island Press,
Washington D.C., USA.
Mori, A.S.
(2011a) Ecosystem management based on natural disturbances: hierarchical
context and non-equilibrium paradigm. Journal of Applied Ecology
48:280-292.
Mori, A.S.
(2011b) Making society more resilient. Nature 484:284.